text string |
|---|
# BUSCO version is: 5.8.0 |
# The lineage dataset is: bacillales_odb10 (Creation date: 2021-02-23, number of genomes: 412, number of BUSCOs: 450) |
# Summarized benchmarking in BUSCO notation for file /mnt/pulsar/files/staging/12682572/working/input.fa |
# BUSCO was run in mode: prok_genome_prod |
# Gene predictor used: prodigal |
***** Results: ***** |
C:94.0%[S:93.8%,D:0.2%],F:3.1%,M:2.9%,n:450 |
423 Complete BUSCOs (C) |
422 Complete and single-copy BUSCOs (S) |
1 Complete and duplicated BUSCOs (D) |
14 Fragmented BUSCOs (F) |
13 Missing BUSCOs (M) |
450 Total BUSCO groups searched |
Assembly Statistics: |
21 Number of scaffolds |
21 Number of contigs |
3992854 Total length |
0.000% Percent gaps |
517 KB Scaffold N50 |
517 KB Contigs N50 |
Dependencies and versions: |
hmmsearch: 3.4 |
bbtools: None |
prodigal: 2.6.3 |
python: sys.version_info(major=3, minor=10, micro=16, releaselevel='final', serial=0) |
busco: 5.8.0 |
# BUSCO version is: 5.8.0 |
# The lineage dataset is: bacillales_odb10 (Creation date: 2021-02-23, number of genomes: 412, number of BUSCOs: 450) |
# Summarized benchmarking in BUSCO notation for file /mnt/pulsar/files/staging/12682567/working/input.fa |
# BUSCO was run in mode: prok_genome_prod |
# Gene predictor used: prodigal |
***** Results: ***** |
C:36.0%[S:36.0%,D:0.0%],F:38.9%,M:25.1%,n:450 |
162 Complete BUSCOs (C) |
162 Complete and single-copy BUSCOs (S) |
0 Complete and duplicated BUSCOs (D) |
175 Fragmented BUSCOs (F) |
113 Missing BUSCOs (M) |
450 Total BUSCO groups searched |
Assembly Statistics: |
21 Number of scaffolds |
21 Number of contigs |
3982784 Total length |
0.000% Percent gaps |
516 KB Scaffold N50 |
516 KB Contigs N50 |
Dependencies and versions: |
hmmsearch: 3.4 |
bbtools: None |
prodigal: 2.6.3 |
python: sys.version_info(major=3, minor=10, micro=16, releaselevel='final', serial=0) |
busco: 5.8.0 |
# BUSCO version is: 5.8.0 |
# The lineage dataset is: bacillales_odb10 (Creation date: 2021-02-23, number of genomes: 412, number of BUSCOs: 450) |
# Summarized benchmarking in BUSCO notation for file /mnt/pulsar/files/staging/12682562/working/input.fa |
# BUSCO was run in mode: prok_genome_prod |
# Gene predictor used: prodigal |
***** Results: ***** |
C:99.1%[S:98.9%,D:0.2%],F:0.9%,M:0.0%,n:450 |
446 Complete BUSCOs (C) |
445 Complete and single-copy BUSCOs (S) |
1 Complete and duplicated BUSCOs (D) |
4 Fragmented BUSCOs (F) |
0 Missing BUSCOs (M) |
450 Total BUSCO groups searched |
Assembly Statistics: |
1 Number of scaffolds |
1 Number of contigs |
4045677 Total length |
0.000% Percent gaps |
4 MB Scaffold N50 |
4 MB Contigs N50 |
Dependencies and versions: |
hmmsearch: 3.4 |
bbtools: None |
prodigal: 2.6.3 |
python: sys.version_info(major=3, minor=10, micro=16, releaselevel='final', serial=0) |
busco: 5.8.0 |
# BUSCO version is: 5.8.0 |
# The lineage dataset is: bacillales_odb10 (Creation date: 2021-02-23, number of genomes: 412, number of BUSCOs: 450) |
# Summarized benchmarking in BUSCO notation for file /mnt/pulsar/files/staging/12682569/working/input.fa |
# BUSCO was run in mode: prok_genome_prod |
# Gene predictor used: prodigal |
***** Results: ***** |
Bioinformatics-Workflow-Bench
142 execution-verified bioinformatics workflow tasks across Galaxy, Nextflow, and WDL platforms.
Overview
Bioinformatics-Workflow-Bench is a unified benchmark for evaluating AI agents on real-world bioinformatics workflow execution tasks. It merges 142 execution-verified tasks from four peer-reviewed sources:
| Source | Platform | Tasks | Ground Truth | Verification Method |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IWC | Galaxy | 75 | Planemo test assertions | CI-verified on every PR |
| nf-core | Nextflow | 45 | nf-test MD5 snapshots | Docker execution + snapshot comparison |
| GTN | Galaxy | 14 | Planemo test assertions | Execution on usegalaxy.org |
| BioWDL / WARP / ENCODE | WDL | 8 | pytest-workflow | miniwdl + Docker execution |
Difficulty distribution: 31 easy, 52 medium, 37 hard, 22 expert.
Every task has been executed end-to-end and its outputs verified against ground truth assertions filed by human domain experts. No task is included based on structural validation alone.
What makes this benchmark different?
- Execution-verified ground truth: Every task has been run on a real compute platform with outputs checked against expert-filed assertions
- Three workflow platforms: Galaxy (.ga), Nextflow (nf-core), and WDL -- tests agent adaptability across ecosystems
- Peer-reviewed workflows: All source workflows passed human code review and automated CI before publication
- Real experimental data: Input data from Zenodo DOIs, nf-core test profiles, or bundled test datasets -- no simulated data
- Three prompt tiers: Each task has open (biological question only), guided (tool names given), and assisted (step-by-step scaffold) prompts
- Task-specific rubrics: Auto-generated evaluation rubrics with expected steps, output assertions, and scoring weights
- Wide domain coverage: 35 domains from genomics to computational chemistry, single-cell to metagenomics
Tasks
Galaxy / IWC (75 tasks)
| # | Task ID | Name | Difficulty | Domain | Steps | Assertions | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | iwc--velocyto |
Velocyto | easy | scRNAseq | 1 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 2 | iwc--avg-bigwig |
Avg Bigwig | easy | other | 2 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 3 | iwc--baredsc |
Baredsc | easy | scRNAseq | 2 | 23 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 4 | iwc--short-read-qc |
Short Read Qc | easy | read-preprocessing | 2 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 5 | iwc--cgmlst-bacterial-genome |
Cgmlst Bacterial Genome | easy | bacterial_genomics | 3 | 7 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 6 | iwc--assembly-with-flye |
Assembly With Flye | easy | genome-assembly | 4 | 10 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 7 | iwc--fastq-to-matrix-10x |
Fastq To Matrix 10X | easy | scRNAseq | 4 | 5 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 8 | iwc--hyphy |
Hyphy | easy | comparative_genomics | 4 | 8 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 9 | iwc--parallel-accession-download |
Parallel Accession Download | easy | data-fetching | 4 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 10 | iwc--qcxms-sdf |
Qcxms Sdf | easy | metabolomics | 4 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 11 | iwc--bacterial-genome-assembly |
Bacterial Genome Assembly | easy | genome-assembly | 5 | 6 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 12 | iwc--brew3r |
Brew3R | easy | transcriptomics | 5 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 13 | iwc--goseq |
Goseq | easy | transcriptomics | 5 | 25 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 14 | iwc--lncrna-annotation |
Lncrna Annotation | easy | genome_annotation | 5 | 10 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 15 | iwc--vgp0-mitogenome |
Vgp0 Mitogenome | easy | VGP-assembly | 5 | 4 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 16 | iwc--annotation-braker3 |
Annotation Braker3 | medium | genome_annotation | 6 | 12 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 17 | iwc--amr-gene-detection |
Amr Gene Detection | medium | other | 7 | 21 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 18 | iwc--annotation-helixer |
Annotation Helixer | medium | genome_annotation | 7 | 13 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 19 | iwc--chipseq-pe |
Chipseq Pe | medium | epigenetics | 7 | 18 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 20 | iwc--chipseq-sr |
Chipseq Sr | medium | epigenetics | 7 | 18 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 21 | iwc--gcms-metams |
Gcms Metams | medium | metabolomics | 7 | 7 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 22 | iwc--nuclei-segmentation |
Nuclei Segmentation | medium | imaging | 7 | 3 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 23 | iwc--raw-reads-qc |
Raw Reads Qc | medium | other | 7 | 10 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 24 | iwc--annotation-maker |
Annotation Maker | medium | genome_annotation | 8 | 19 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 25 | iwc--openms-metaprosip |
Openms Metaprosip | medium | proteomics | 8 | 6 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 26 | iwc--polish-long-reads |
Polish Long Reads | medium | other | 8 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 27 | iwc--bacterial-genome-annotation |
Bacterial Genome Annotation | medium | bacterial_genomics | 9 | 15 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 28 | iwc--cutandrun |
Cutandrun | medium | epigenetics | 9 | 17 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 29 | iwc--mfassignr |
Mfassignr | medium | metabolomics | 9 | 15 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 30 | iwc--protein-ligand-param |
Protein Ligand Param | medium | other | 9 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 31 | iwc--sars-cov2-se-wgs |
Sars Cov2 Se Wgs | medium | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 9 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 32 | iwc--mag-genome-annotation-parallel |
Mag Genome Annotation Parallel | medium | microbiome | 10 | 7 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 33 | iwc--fragment-docking |
Fragment Docking | medium | computational-chemistry | 11 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 34 | iwc--rnaseq-sr |
Rnaseq Sr | medium | transcriptomics | 11 | 9 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 35 | iwc--sars-cov2-pe-wgs |
Sars Cov2 Pe Wgs | medium | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 11 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 36 | iwc--vgp2-kmer-trio |
Vgp2 Kmer Trio | medium | VGP-assembly | 11 | 7 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 37 | iwc--vgp9-decontamination |
Vgp9 Decontamination | medium | VGP-assembly | 11 | 18 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 38 | iwc--generic-vc |
Generic Vc | medium | other | 12 | 5 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 39 | iwc--lcms-preprocessing |
Lcms Preprocessing | medium | metabolomics | 12 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 40 | iwc--ploidy-vc |
Ploidy Vc | medium | other | 12 | 8 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 41 | iwc--rnaseq-pe |
Rnaseq Pe | medium | transcriptomics | 12 | 11 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 42 | iwc--vgp7-scaffolding-bionano |
Vgp7 Scaffolding Bionano | medium | VGP-assembly | 12 | 5 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 43 | iwc--bacterial-qc-post-assembly |
Bacterial Qc Post Assembly | medium | bacterial_genomics | 13 | 18 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 44 | iwc--haploid-vc |
Haploid Vc | medium | other | 13 | 4 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 45 | iwc--pseudobulk-decoupler-edger |
Pseudobulk Decoupler Edger | medium | other | 13 | 5 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 46 | iwc--sra-manifest-fastqs |
Sra Manifest Fastqs | medium | other | 13 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 47 | iwc--dada2 |
Dada2 | medium | amplicon | 14 | 9 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 48 | iwc--vgp-plot-nx-size |
Vgp Plot Nx Size | medium | VGP-assembly | 14 | 4 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 49 | iwc--vgp1-kmer-profiling |
Vgp1 Kmer Profiling | medium | VGP-assembly | 14 | 9 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 50 | iwc--gromacs-mmgbsa |
Gromacs Mmgbsa | hard | computational-chemistry | 17 | 4 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 51 | iwc--rnaseq-de |
Rnaseq De | hard | transcriptomics | 17 | 6 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 52 | iwc--sars-cov2-consensus |
Sars Cov2 Consensus | hard | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 17 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 53 | iwc--metagenomic-raw-reads-amr |
Metagenomic Raw Reads Amr | hard | microbiome | 20 | 22 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 54 | iwc--sars-cov2-ivar |
Sars Cov2 Ivar | hard | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 20 | 5 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 55 | iwc--gromacs-dctmd |
Gromacs Dctmd | hard | computational-chemistry | 21 | 6 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 56 | iwc--consensus-peaks |
Consensus Peaks | hard | epigenetics | 22 | 7 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 57 | iwc--mags-taxonomy-annotation |
Mags Taxonomy Annotation | hard | microbiome | 22 | 14 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 58 | iwc--sars-cov2-ont-artic |
Sars Cov2 Ont Artic | hard | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 22 | 1 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 59 | iwc--viral-generic |
Viral Generic | hard | other | 23 | 13 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 60 | iwc--sars-cov2-pe-artic |
Sars Cov2 Pe Artic | hard | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 25 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 61 | iwc--atacseq |
Atacseq | hard | epigenetics | 27 | 19 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 62 | iwc--sars-cov2-reporting |
Sars Cov2 Reporting | hard | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 30 | 2 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 63 | iwc--variation-reporting |
Variation Reporting | hard | sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 31 | 4 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 64 | iwc--metagenomic-genes-catalogue |
Metagenomic Genes Catalogue | hard | microbiome | 33 | 17 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 65 | iwc--vgp6b-purge-dups-haplotype |
Vgp6B Purge Dups Haplotype | hard | VGP-assembly | 35 | 10 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 66 | iwc--mags-building |
Mags Building | expert | microbiome | 38 | 5 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 67 | iwc--vgp3-hifi-assembly |
Vgp3 Hifi Assembly | expert | VGP-assembly | 42 | 11 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 68 | iwc--vgp5-hifi-trio-assembly |
Vgp5 Hifi Trio Assembly | expert | VGP-assembly | 44 | 8 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 69 | iwc--vgp6-purge-dups |
Vgp6 Purge Dups | expert | VGP-assembly | 45 | 13 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 70 | iwc--binning-evaluation |
Binning Evaluation | expert | microbiome | 47 | 7 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 71 | iwc--influenza |
Influenza | expert | virology | 54 | 8 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 72 | iwc--scanpy-clustering |
Scanpy Clustering | expert | scRNAseq | 55 | 51 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 73 | iwc--vgp8-scaffolding-hic |
Vgp8 Scaffolding Hic | expert | VGP-assembly | 55 | 17 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 74 | iwc--hic-contact-map |
Hic Contact Map | expert | VGP-assembly | 56 | 22 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
| 75 | iwc--vgp4-hifi-hic-assembly |
Vgp4 Hifi Hic Assembly | expert | VGP-assembly | 57 | 22 | IWC Planemo CI verified |
Galaxy / GTN (14 tasks)
| # | Task ID | Name | Difficulty | Domain | Steps | Assertions | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | gtn--abc_intro_phylo |
Abc Intro Phylo | easy | evolution | 3 | 3 | Verified with planemo test on usegalaxy.org. All assertions passed. |
| 2 | gtn--bacterial-isolate-species-contamination-checking |
Bacterial Isolate Species Contamination Checking | easy | ecology | 3 | 5 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 3 | gtn--mitochondrion-assembly |
Mitochondrion Assembly | easy | assembly | 3 | 4 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 4 | gtn--quality-contamination-control |
Quality Contamination Control | easy | sequence-analysis | 5 | 6 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 5 | gtn--small_ncrna_clustering |
Small Ncrna Clustering | easy | transcriptomics | 5 | 4 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 6 | gtn--mrsa-illumina |
Mrsa Illumina | medium | assembly | 6 | 4 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 7 | gtn--unicycler-assembly |
Unicycler Assembly | medium | assembly | 6 | 3 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 8 | gtn--med-chem-data |
Med Chem Data | medium | comp-chem | 7 | 8 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 9 | gtn--scrna-raceid |
Scrna Raceid | medium | scRNAseq | 8 | 3 | Verified interactively on usegalaxy.org. All 23 jobs completed. Trajectory analy |
| 10 | gtn--galaxy-intro-101-everyone |
Galaxy Intro 101 Everyone | medium | introductory | 9 | 4 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 11 | gtn--assembly-decontamination |
Assembly Decontamination | medium | assembly | 10 | 3 | Verified with planemo test on usegalaxy.org. All assertions passed. |
| 12 | gtn--hybrid_denovo_assembly |
Hybrid Denovo Assembly | medium | assembly | 12 | 11 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 13 | gtn--gtn-hic-drosophila |
Gtn Hic Drosophila | hard | epigenetics | 18 | 2 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
| 14 | gtn--tal1-binding-site-identification |
Tal1 Binding Site Identification | expert | epigenetics | 57 | 3 | Verified on usegalaxy.org |
Nextflow / nf-core (45 tasks)
| # | Task ID | Name | Difficulty | Domain | Steps | Assertions | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | nfcore--metaboigniter |
nf-core/metaboigniter | easy | metagenomics | 2 | 3 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 2 | nfcore--ribomsqc |
nf-core/ribomsqc | easy | other | 2 | 14 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 3 | nfcore--drugresponseeval |
nf-core/drugresponseeval | easy | other | 3 | 10 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 4 | nfcore--nanostring |
nf-core/nanostring | easy | gene-expression | 3 | 13 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 5 | nfcore--fetchngs |
nf-core/fetchngs | easy | metagenomics | 4 | 55 | 27/30 strict MD5 match. 2 'missing' are pipeline_info files with timestamps in f |
| 6 | nfcore--epitopeprediction |
nf-core/epitopeprediction | easy | other | 5 | 139 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 7 | nfcore--detaxizer |
nf-core/detaxizer | medium | other | 8 | 46 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 8 | nfcore--fastqrepair |
nf-core/fastqrepair | medium | other | 8 | 39 | 15/30 strict MD5 match. All 15 mismatches are MultiQC report files (SVG plots, l |
| 9 | nfcore--molkart |
nf-core/molkart | medium | other | 8 | 18 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 10 | nfcore--airrflow |
nf-core/airrflow | medium | other | 9 | 51 | Docker-only pipeline. 18/18 snapshot MD5s matched on Docker profile. |
| 11 | nfcore--readsimulator |
nf-core/readsimulator | medium | simulation | 9 | 8 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 12 | nfcore--hic |
nf-core/hic | medium | 3d-genome | 10 | 18 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 13 | nfcore--bamtofastq |
nf-core/bamtofastq | medium | other | 12 | 34 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 14 | nfcore--pairgenomealign |
nf-core/pairgenomealign | medium | sequence-analysis | 12 | 20 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 15 | nfcore--mhcquant |
nf-core/mhcquant | medium | proteomics | 13 | 107 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 16 | nfcore--isoseq |
nf-core/isoseq | medium | transcriptomics | 14 | 148 | 20/30 strict MD5 match. 15 expected files are BAM/PBI excluded from MD5 computat |
| 17 | nfcore--phyloplace |
nf-core/phyloplace | medium | other | 15 | 31 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 18 | nfcore--coproid |
nf-core/coproid | hard | other | 16 | 1 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 19 | nfcore--pangenome |
nf-core/pangenome | hard | pangenomics | 16 | 39 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 20 | nfcore--demultiplex |
nf-core/demultiplex | hard | data-processing | 17 | 301 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 21 | nfcore--differentialabundance |
nf-core/differentialabundance | hard | other | 19 | 53 | Conda GUNZIP path unresolvable. Docker profile works. Verified on Docker worksta |
| 22 | nfcore--createtaxdb |
nf-core/createtaxdb | hard | metagenomics | 20 | 21 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 23 | nfcore--scrnaseq |
nf-core/scrnaseq | hard | transcriptomics | 20 | 136 | Docker-only pipeline (CELLRANGERARC_COUNT requires Docker). Verified on Docker w |
| 24 | nfcore--magmap |
nf-core/magmap | hard | metagenomics | 21 | 80 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 25 | nfcore--pacvar |
nf-core/pacvar | hard | variant-calling | 21 | 12 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 26 | nfcore--genomeassembler |
nf-core/genomeassembler | hard | assembly | 22 | 33 | 7/8 strict MD5 match. 1 mismatch is assembler output (Flye/Hifiasm non-determini |
| 27 | nfcore--methylong |
nf-core/methylong | hard | epigenetics | 23 | 38 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 28 | nfcore--metatdenovo |
nf-core/metatdenovo | hard | metagenomics | 24 | 5 | 0/5 strict MD5 match. All 5 expected entries are 'versions.yml' from different m |
| 29 | nfcore--scnanoseq |
nf-core/scnanoseq | hard | scRNAseq | 25 | 2 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 30 | nfcore--smrnaseq |
nf-core/smrnaseq | hard | transcriptomics | 30 | 156 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 31 | nfcore--multiplesequencealign |
nf-core/multiplesequencealign | hard | sequence-analysis | 31 | 16 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 32 | nfcore--atacseq |
nf-core/atacseq | hard | epigenetics | 34 | 189 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. (Failed on cond |
| 33 | nfcore--chipseq |
nf-core/chipseq | hard | epigenetics | 34 | 397 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 34 | nfcore--callingcards |
nf-core/callingcards | hard | other | 35 | 370 | 25/30 strict MD5 match. 5 mismatches are biologically equivalent: genes.bed (ref |
| 35 | nfcore--variantbenchmarking |
nf-core/variantbenchmarking | expert | variant-calling | 36 | 52 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 36 | nfcore--pathogensurveillance |
nf-core/pathogensurveillance | expert | other | 37 | 73 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 37 | nfcore--methylseq |
nf-core/methylseq | expert | epigenetics | 39 | 134 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
| 38 | nfcore--phaseimpute |
nf-core/phaseimpute | expert | other | 39 | 13 | 0/12 on conda (all MD5 mismatch). Docker profile produces correct outputs. Verif |
| 39 | nfcore--riboseq |
nf-core/riboseq | expert | other | 40 | 231 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 40 | nfcore--rnavar |
nf-core/rnavar | expert | transcriptomics | 41 | 27 | 21/25 strict MD5 match. 2 'missing' are BAM files excluded from MD5 by design (. |
| 41 | nfcore--nascent |
nf-core/nascent | expert | other | 51 | 67 | 23/30 strict MD5 match. 7 mismatches are biologically equivalent: 6 samtools sta |
| 42 | nfcore--taxprofiler |
nf-core/taxprofiler | expert | metagenomics | 53 | 7 | 7/7 strict MD5 match (100%). Pipeline exit=1 from a non-essential late step. All |
| 43 | nfcore--viralrecon |
nf-core/viralrecon | expert | variant-calling | 57 | 158 | Verified on Docker workstation. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 44 | nfcore--viralmetagenome |
nf-core/viralmetagenome | expert | variant-calling | 69 | 258 | 22/30 strict MD5 match. 8 mismatches are biologically equivalent: all are assemb |
| 45 | nfcore--rnaseq |
nf-core/rnaseq | expert | transcriptomics | 70 | 657 | Verified with nf-test snapshots |
WDL (8 tasks)
| # | Task ID | Name | Difficulty | Domain | Steps | Assertions | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | wdl--qc |
Qc | easy | quality-control | 2 | 91 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 2 | wdl--aligning |
Aligning | easy | alignment | 4 | 8 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 3 | wdl--expression_quantification |
Expression Quantification | easy | transcriptomics | 4 | 32 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. |
| 4 | wdl--bam_metrics |
Bam Metrics | easy | quality-control | 5 | 70 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 5 | wdl--gatk_preprocess |
Gatk Preprocess | easy | preprocessing | 5 | 9 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 6 | wdl--gatk_variantcalling |
Gatk Variantcalling | hard | variant-calling | 17 | 51 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. Pipeline completed successfully (exit 0). |
| 7 | wdl--structural_variantcalling |
Structural Variantcalling | hard | variant-calling | 23 | 20 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. Pipeline completed successfully. |
| 8 | wdl--somatic_variantcalling |
Somatic Variantcalling | hard | variant-calling | 25 | 308 | Verified with miniwdl + Docker. Pipeline completed successfully (exit 0). |
# Clone
git clone https://github.com/lingzhi227/Bioinformatics-Workflow-Bench.git
cd Bioinformatics-Workflow-Bench
# List all tasks
python src/dataset.py list-tasks
# Filter by platform or difficulty
python src/dataset.py list-tasks --platform galaxy
python src/dataset.py list-tasks --difficulty hard
# Show task details
python src/dataset.py show-task --task iwc--rnaseq-pe
# Show ground truth assertions
python src/dataset.py show-assertions --task nfcore--rnaseq
# Download input data
python src/dataset.py download --task gtn--mrsa-illumina
Task format
tasks/{source}--{task-id}/
prompt_open.md # Biological question only (agent must infer tools and pipeline)
prompt_guided.md # Pipeline structure with tool names
prompt_assisted.md # Step-by-step scaffold with verification hints
rubric.json # Evaluation rubric (steps, assertions, scoring weights)
# Platform-specific files:
# Galaxy (IWC/GTN):
workflow/
*.ga # Galaxy workflow file
*-tests.yml # Planemo test assertions (ground truth)
test-data/ # Local test data (if any)
environment.yml # Conda environment
Dockerfile # Container definition
run_script.sh # Execution script (IWC only)
# Nextflow (nf-core):
nfcore/
test.config # Nextflow test configuration
nextflow_schema.json # Parameter schema
tests/*.nf.test # nf-test definitions
tests/*.nf.test.snap # Snapshot assertions (MD5 ground truth)
test_config.txt # Original test config
# WDL:
wdl/
*.wdl # WDL workflow files
tests/
*.json # Input JSONs
data/ # Test data
Prompt tiers
prompt_open.md: Describes only the biological objective. The agent must determine which tools, pipeline, and parameters to use. Tests biological reasoning + autonomous planning.prompt_guided.md: Provides the pipeline structure with tool names. Tests whether the agent can execute a known workflow correctly.prompt_assisted.md: Adds explicit step ordering and verification targets. Tests reproducibility with reduced planning ambiguity.
The delta across open/guided/assisted scores reveals where agents struggle: biological reasoning, tool selection, or faithful execution.
rubric.json schema
{
"task_id": "iwc--rnaseq-pe",
"original_task_id": "rnaseq-pe",
"platform": "galaxy",
"source": "IWC",
"verification": "execution-verified",
"metadata": {
"difficulty": "medium",
"domain": "transcriptomics",
"biological_steps": 6,
"assertion_count": 24,
"primary_tools": ["hisat2", "featurecounts", "deseq2"]
},
"scoring_weights": {
"pipeline_completion": 0.4,
"result_correctness": 0.4,
"biological_validity": 0.2
}
}
Evaluation
# Deterministic rubric-based evaluation
python scripts/eval_agent.py --task iwc--rnaseq-pe --workspace /path/to/agent/output
# Agentic LLM judge (requires OpenAI API key)
python scripts/judge_agent.py --task nfcore--rnaseq --workspace /path/to/output \
--api-key "$OPENAI_API_KEY"
Scoring formula: 40% pipeline completion + 40% result correctness + 20% biological validity.
Domain coverage
| Domain | Tasks | Platforms |
|---|---|---|
| other | 27 | galaxy, nextflow |
| VGP-assembly | 13 | galaxy |
| transcriptomics | 12 | galaxy, nextflow, wdl |
| epigenetics | 11 | galaxy, nextflow |
| sars-cov-2-variant-calling | 8 | galaxy |
| variant-calling | 7 | nextflow, wdl |
| scRNAseq | 6 | galaxy, nextflow |
| microbiome | 6 | galaxy |
| metagenomics | 6 | nextflow |
| assembly | 6 | galaxy, nextflow |
| genome_annotation | 4 | galaxy |
| metabolomics | 4 | galaxy |
| bacterial_genomics | 3 | galaxy |
| computational-chemistry | 3 | galaxy |
| sequence-analysis | 3 | galaxy, nextflow |
| genome-assembly | 2 | galaxy |
| proteomics | 2 | galaxy, nextflow |
| quality-control | 2 | wdl |
| amplicon | 1 | galaxy |
| comparative_genomics | 1 | galaxy |
Provenance
This benchmark merges execution-verified tasks from four independently maintained repositories:
- IWC-bench (75 tasks): Galaxy Intergalactic Workflow Commission workflows with Planemo CI
- nf-core-bench (45 tasks): nf-core Nextflow pipelines with nf-test snapshot verification
- GTN-bench (14 tasks): Galaxy Training Network tutorial workflows verified on usegalaxy.org
- WDL-bench (8 tasks): BioWDL/WARP/ENCODE WDL pipelines verified with miniwdl
Each task directory preserves all original files from its source repository. The rubric.json contains original_task_id and source fields for full traceability.
Citation
@article{hiltemann2023galaxy,
title={Galaxy Training: A powerful framework for teaching!},
author={Hiltemann, Saskia and others},
journal={PLoS Computational Biology},
volume={19},
pages={e1010752},
year={2023}
}
@article{ewels2020nf,
title={The nf-core framework for community-curated bioinformatics pipelines},
author={Ewels, Philip A and others},
journal={Nature Biotechnology},
volume={38},
pages={276--278},
year={2020}
}
- Downloads last month
- 7